Kotaro wins Lock

[shadow-zero]

hmm? points? well...thanks! -is slightly confused-

[Zkaiser]

I pretty much agree with everyone else.

WiiOmi's cards have OCG errors, other than that I actually like his effects. Not more than Kotaro's though.

The only thing I don't like about Kotaro's cards is the fact that "civilization" is misspelled. Also, I don't find Kotaro's Field Spell to be creative at all. All it does is summon the monster. I believe that it should have done something else as well.

[Zexion]

I vote for Kotaro's cards.
I see his cards seem to have better pictures and more creative effects.
It is also balanced.

[Santa's Little Helper]

(11-07-2009 12:23 PM)Zkaiser Wrote:  I pretty much agree with everyone else.

WiiOmi's cards have OCG errors, other than that I actually like his effects. Not more than Kotaro's though.

The only thing I don't like about Kotaro's cards is the fact that "civilization" is misspelled. Also, I don't find Kotaro's Field Spell to be creative at all. All it does is summon the monster. I believe that it should have done something else as well.

Read the challange
it needs to summon the monster
Vote Accepted

(11-07-2009 12:24 PM)Zexion Wrote:  I vote for Kotaro's cards.
I see his cards seem to have better pictures and more creative effects.
It is also balanced.

Vote accepted



Kotaro wins

[Zkaiser]

(11-07-2009 12:38 PM)Dog King Wrote:  

(11-07-2009 12:23 PM)Zkaiser Wrote:  I pretty much agree with everyone else.

WiiOmi's cards have OCG errors, other than that I actually like his effects. Not more than Kotaro's though.

The only thing I don't like about Kotaro's cards is the fact that "civilization" is misspelled. Also, I don't find Kotaro's Field Spell to be creative at all. All it does is summon the monster. I believe that it should have done something else as well.

Read the challange
it needs to summon the monster
Vote Accepted

What I meant was that summoning the monster was ALL the field spell did. I think it should have done more.

[Santa's Little Helper]

No all it needs to summon is the monster

[shadow-zero]

you are wrong. in special summoning a monster, it should be allowed to give it some type of atk/def increase, since it does not increase the atk/def of monsters on the field. any refusal to acknowledge this fact shall result in a very stern objection. you don't want that.